Twisting "God Bless Us" by Christopher Beam
Posted by Melvin Bray on May 2nd, 2008 filed in Useful PerhapsOn today’s “state of the race†conference call, a reporter asked about an exchange between Hillary Clinton and Bill O’Reilly on yesterday’s show in which Clinton uttered the words, “Rich people—God bless us.â€
Clinton spokesman Howard Wolfson denied that’s what she said: “She said ‘God blessed us.’ B-L-E-S-S-E-D.â€
That may be what she meant. But it’s definitely not what she said. I just watched the video again with headphones and cranked the volume way up. Not a trace of plosive after the sibilant.
Here’s the full context, as described by the Huffington Post:
[O’Reilly said,] “I’m not middle class, I’m a rich guy.†Clinton responded (in an awkward moment), “Rich people, God bless us. We deserve all the opportunities to make sure our country and our blessings continue until the next generation.â€
This is not controversial. People know Clinton is rich. It’s common for [some] Christians to believe that wealthy people are blessed by God. And the phrase “God bless us” used in this context doesn’t mean she’s demanding that God smile upon the rich [(that’s what the follow-up sentence was for)]; it’s clearly a lead-in to her point that wealthy people don’t need all their money. Don’t get me wrong—it will make a great clip for the next MoveOn.org ad. But in context, it’s a reasonable statement.
So why lie about it?






Leave a Comment